Data Layer for Google Analytics and Adobe Analytics

Adobe Analytics BCS 6 years ago (2019-12-18) 3729 Views 0 Comments

Update time: June 11, 2025

In the realm of web analytics, the data layer serves as a critical component for ensuring accurate and efficient data collection. Both Google Analytics and Adobe Analytics rely on data layers to capture and transmit website data, but their approaches differ significantly in structure, functionality, and implementation. This article explores the key differences and similarities between the data layers used in Google Analytics and Adobe Analytics, helping you understand which might better suit your business needs

What is a Data Layer?

A data layer is a JavaScript object embedded in a website’s code that stores and organizes data to be passed to analytics tools, tag management systems, or other tracking platforms. It acts as a standardized intermediary between the website and analytics tools, ensuring consistent and reliable data collection. By using a data layer, businesses can avoid scraping HTML elements for data, which can break when a website’s structure changes.

For both Google Analytics and Adobe Analytics, the data layer simplifies the process of capturing key user interactions, such as page views, clicks, form submissions, or e-commerce transactions, and makes this data accessible for analysis.

Data Layer for Google Analytics

The Google Analytics data layer, often used with Google Tag Manager (GTM), is a dynamic, event-driven JavaScript object typically named dataLayer. It is designed to capture and push data to GTM, which then forwards it to Google Analytics or other integrated tools. The dataLayer is highly flexible and widely adopted due to Google’s dominance in the analytics space

Structure

The Google Analytics data layer is structured as an array of JavaScript objects, where data is pushed using the dataLayer.push() method. A typical example looks like this:

dataLayer = [{
  'pageCategory': 'signup',
  'visitorType': 'high-value'
}];
When an event occurs (e.g., a purchase), additional data can be dynamically pushed:
dataLayer.push({
  'event': 'purchase',
  'transactionId': '12345',
  'transactionTotal': 99.99
});

This event-driven approach allows GTM to listen for specific event keys and trigger tags accordingly

Key Features

  • Event-Driven: The Google data layer supports asynchronous, event-based data pushes, making it ideal for single-page applications (SPAs) and dynamic websites.
  • Flexibility: It is vendor-agnostic and can be used with various tools beyond Google Analytics, such as advertising platforms or A/B testing tools.
  • Integration with GTM: The data layer is tightly integrated with GTM, enabling easy configuration of triggers and variables without extensive coding.
  • Well-Documented: Google provides extensive documentation, and the prevalence of GTM means many CMS platforms (e.g., Shopify, WordPress) have built-in support for Google’s data layer.

Limitations

  • Dependency on GTM: While the data layer can be used without GTM, it’s most effective when paired with GTM, which may add complexity for small setups.

 

Data layer for Adobe Analytics

Adobe Analytics uses a data layer to collect data for its platform, often in conjunction with Adobe Experience Platform Data Collection (formerly Adobe Launch). Unlike Google’s data layer, Adobe’s data layer is typically a static JavaScript object, though the Adobe Client Data Layer (ACDL) introduces event-driven capabilities similar to Google’s. Adobe’s approach emphasizes enterprise-grade customization and integration with the Adobe Experience Cloud

Structure

A traditional Adobe Analytics data layer is a JavaScript object that holds static values, such as:
window.adobeDataLayer = {
  'pageName': 'Home Page',
  'userType': 'Registered',
  'productPrice': 49.99
};
With the introduction of the ACDL, Adobe supports an event-driven model, allowing data to be pushed dynamically:
adobeDataLayer.push({
  'event': 'productView',
  'productId': 'ABC123',
  'productPrice': 49.99
});

The ACDL aligns more closely with Google’s event-driven structure, making it easier for developers familiar with GTM to adapt

Key Features

  • Adobe Client Data Layer (ACDL): The ACDL is an event-driven data layer that treats all interactions (e.g., page loads, clicks) as events, simplifying implementation for dynamic websites and SPAs.
  • Enterprise Focus: Adobe’s data layer is designed for complex, enterprise-level implementations, offering robust data governance and integration with Adobe Experience Cloud tools.
  • Customizability: Adobe allows organizations to define custom data layer schemas to meet specific tracking needs, with support for extensions like the Customer Experience Digital Data Layer (CEDDL).
  • Direct Call Rules and Custom Events: For scenarios where a static data layer isn’t sufficient, Adobe offers Direct Call Rules and Custom Events to trigger data collection, akin to Google’s dataLayer.push().

Limitations

  • Complexity: Adobe’s data layer, especially without ACDL, can be more complex to set up, requiring collaboration with IT or development teams.
  • Static Nature (Pre-ACDL): Traditional Adobe data layers lack the dynamic, event-driven capabilities of Google’s, though ACDL addresses this.
  • Learning Curve: Developers familiar with Google’s ecosystem may need time to adapt to Adobe’s terminology and structure.

Key Differences Between Google and Adobe Data Layers

Aspect
Google Analytics Data Layer
Adobe Analytics Data Layer
Structure
Event-driven array (dataLayer.push)
Static object (traditional); Event-driven with ACDL
Primary Use Case
Flexible, general-purpose for GTM and multiple tools
Enterprise-grade, tailored for Adobe Experience Cloud
Event Handling
Native support for dynamic events via
push
Direct Call Rules, Custom Events, or ACDL for events
Integration
Tightly integrated with GTM and Google ecosystem
Integrated with Adobe Experience Platform and Launch
Ease of Implementation
Simpler, well-documented, vendor-agnostic
More complex, requires planning and technical expertise
Flexibility
Highly flexible but prone to inconsistency without governance
Highly customizable with strong governance features
Documentation
Extensive, community-supported
Detailed but Adobe-specific, less community content

Can You Use the Same Data Layer for Both?

A common question is whether a single data layer can serve both Google Analytics and Adobe Analytics. Traditionally, the answer was no, as Google’s event-driven dataLayer and Adobe’s static data layer had different structures and purposes.
However, the Adobe Client Data Layer (ACDL) changes this. ACDL can be leveraged to support both Google Analytics and Adobe Analytics, reducing the need for duplicate data layers. By cloning and cleaning an existing Google-style data layer, organizations can make data available to both GTM and Adobe Launch, streamlining implementation and reducing maintenance costs. This approach is particularly useful during migrations or when running both platforms in parallel.

If you don't understand, You can leave a comment below.
Like (7)
Post my comment
Cancel comment
Expression Bold Strikethrough Center Italic

Hi, you need to fill in your nickname and email!

  • Nickname (required)
  • Email (required)
  • Website